REVIEW: Liberty by Kimberly Iverson

Dear Ms. Iverson,

This turned out to be a lucky gamble book. And what made it even longer odds that I picked it up to try is that all I initially saw on the shelf at Waldenbooks was the spine. Let’s hear it for great cover/spine artwork. Yes, publishers, it really can sell your books. And for those interested, it’s also available as an ebook. And damn, it’s got a great UK cover as well.

After the wild Picts attacked her family’s farm near of Hadrian’s Wall, Rhyddes’s life quickly goes from being difficult to unbearable. Her father has always hated her but Rhyddes never thought he would take the opportunity of increased Roman taxes to get rid of her. She quickly finds herself sold as a slave, brutalized by the soldiers who deliver her to the slaver in Londinium then bought by Jamil, an Egyptian lanista who hopes that adding a female to his troop of gladiators will pay off his enormous investment in her.

Marcus Calpurnius Aquila doesn’t care that his career in the arena scandalizes his father, the Roman governor of Britannia. This is what he loves doing and Marcus knows he fights well enough that the risk of him dying there is slim. But when his father seeks to further his political ambitions by betrothing Marcus to the daughter of a powerful Roman senator, Marcus also knows he has no choice but to obey. Roman fathers hold the power of life or death over their children.

After agreeing to the betrothal and to stop actual gladiatorial matches, Marcus is allowed to continue sparring with Jamil’s gladiators and uses that to allow him to further his knowledge of this determined Celtic gladiatrix. Rhyddes is like no woman Marcus has ever known and he quickly finds himself losing his heart to her. But Rhyddes needs time to overcome her hatred of all things Roman before she begins to return his feelings. They both know their chance of a life together is nonexistent since Marcus is nobility and by becoming a gladiator Rhyddes has joined the ranks of the infamia, “the infamous ones” who are one step above common criminals. But when a conspiracy plot against the Emperor, Marcus Aurelius, is uncovered, both wonder if they will even survive at all.

I know from your author note that you took a few liberties with known historic facts to tell this story but you work everything so seamlessly into the book that it’s hard to tell. I was especially impressed by how you convey the meaning of things which were common place in this era but which modern readers might not know. It’s a hard balancing act and I applaud you.

I also like how you give depth to each character. Rhyddes isn’t just a red haired spitfire and Marcus is more than an arrogant Roman. You also do a great job painting a vivid image of Londinium and Rome, warts and all, but without making it too gross for modern readers. I did get a little tired of every male either falling in love with Rhyddes or wanting to shag her and Marcus might have been a bit too touchy feely but overall, this is a dynamic jump back in time. B+

Oh and in case readers want to know, you include the information about how to pronounce Rhyddes’ name: “hree-dthes.” I hate reading a book where I can’t mentally pronounce a character’s name. Thank you.



0 comments on “REVIEW: Liberty by Kimberly Iverson

  1. This has been on my TBR pile since it was released few months ago. The cover art caught my attention…plus, I had just read Michelle Styles’ gladiator HH and was interested in reading more set in the Roman empire. I put off reading it because it got such a low grade at AAR and was worried that it might not live up to my expectations. But I’m thinking now that it’ll be the book I read while traveling next week. Thanks for the excellent review, Jayne.

  2. ITA about the cover art. What do you think of the UK version. I was hunting for the cover to upload it here and found that one. Damn, I almost wish I had it instead.

    I didn’t know AAR had review it. Must check that out.

    I just finished reading Michelle Styles next Roman era book and liked it better than Gladiator. Bad news is that I don’t know when it will be published in the US. Bad Mills and Boon, bad, bad!

  3. FYI, both Kimberly (Iverson) and Michelle (Styles) have joined my multi-person blog for authors who write historicals set in unusual times/places. Jennifer Mueller, whose books you reviewed earlier this month, is also a contributor.

    Thanks for this review of Liberty — it’s first on my list of Christmas down-time reads.

  4. Jayne, thank you so much for your terrific review of LIBERTY! Until your article, I had been getting the best reviews from men. I seem to have written a book that readers either love or hate — if you’ve seen the AAR review you know what I mean. But that’s OK; as a reviewer myself, I find it’s the books that fall in the middle, evoking no real emotional response one way or the other, that I feel I’ve truly wasted my time upon.

    Regarding the alternate cover, the one depicting the heroine & hero against a gorgeous backdrop of the Colosseum, that was the old cover, which was abandoned 6 months prior to publication but still shows up as a graphic on some online bookstore sites. I don’t believe that represents a different “UK edition” since the original cover dimensions are different. But who knows?? If any UK readers have seen it “in the flesh,” so to speak, I’d love to hear about it.

    Since you have been so kind, Jayne, then if you would like to email me your “earthmail” address I would be delighted to send you a signed cover flat of the original cover art — a true collector’s item because I have only a couple of them . . .

    Take care and Happy Holidays!
    Kim D Headlee
    Author, LIBERTY, writing as Kimberly Iverson, HQN Books, ISBN 0373771347, on sale now
    Author, DAWNFLIGHT, ISBN 0671020412
    Contributor, THE FANTASY WRITER’S COMPANION, ISBN 1896944159

  5. Well damn, that’s a great cover that never was then. 😉

    I finally got a chance to read the AAR review yesterday and it’s pretty harsh. But the TRR one is a 4 heart so I guess it is a love it or hate it kind of book.

    I’m curious, what have men been saying about it and do you consider this to be a romance book? Do they consider it to be one? I did find it shelved with the romance books at Waldenbooks.

  6. Jayne, yes I consider LIBERTY to be a romance, but with a broader-than-usual scope in terms of plot, development of secondary characters, other types of relationships than romantic ones, and other thematic subtexts as well. That’s just how I craft stories.

    Most men I’ve heard from to date, either via fan mail or reviews, who have liked the book seem to have liked it for many of the reasons I’ve mentioned above. LIBERTY, apparently, has shattered their pre-conceived notions of historical romances (and could explain why some women don’t like this book). A good example is this review, posted by the webmaster of, here.

    Fans reading this page who would like to give LIBERTY a boost can also post their views on and, where other harsh comments have been posted.


  7. Update: read Liberty on my travel day. Wow, loved it. Went backk and re-read the AAR review and wondered if we read the same book. In some ways, Liberty reminded me of a sweeping, epic-saga style 80s book — and I mean that in a good way! I suppose if I was looking for a straight romance, I might have been a little disappointed that Rhyddes and Marcus didn’t spend a great deal of time together on the page. But I felt like there was enough, and I found the historical detail and the political machinations to be fascinating!

  8. jmc, I was amazed by the AAR review myself. Maybe that reviewer didn’t enjoy the political machinations but I loved them too. I jut got the cover flats from Kim Headlee and the old one (that I mistakenly thought was the UK cover) is gorgeous. I’m almost sorry it wasn’t the final choice but it probably would have been impossible to get a man to read any book using it. [grin]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s